Sophia Soraya
February 18, 2025
If you’re searching for answers to the question, “My dog attacked another dog, will it be put down?” know that you aren’t alone. There comes a responsibility along with pet ownership, and after an incident like this, you are apprehensive about what will happen to your dog in the future. At Varcadipane & Pinnisi, P.C., we understand how upsetting these situations are, and we’re here to help you navigate the legal aspects and protect your dog’s rights.
What can happen if my dog bit another dog?
You may be liable for damages if your dog bites another dog. The injured dog’s owner could seek reimbursement for veterinary bills or other expenses. In New Jersey, liability often depends on whether your dog has a history of aggression or if the bite occurred due to negligence, such as not restraining your pet in a public space.
In many cases, incidents between dogs are handled as civil issues rather than criminal offenses. Of course, this could easily escalate based on the severity of the injury or perhaps because local ordinances classify the event as part of a “dangerous dog” investigation. The American Veterinary Medical Association estimates that nearly 40% of U.S. households have canine companions, and therefore, such cases become increasingly prevalent.
Can my dog be put down?
Yes, but only under specific legal circumstances. In New Jersey, a dog may face euthanasia if it has been proven to cause “serious bodily injury to another domestic animal or killed another domestic animal,” as stated in N.J.S.A. 4:19-23.
However, this is not done lightly. In most cases, animal control will investigate the situation by considering prior histories of aggression, witness accounts, veterinarian reports, and other forms of evidence. You have the right to contest any findings during a legal hearing, and having an experienced attorney can be critical to protecting your pet from unnecessary euthanasia.
Steps to take after a dog bite
If your dog has bitten another dog, acting promptly and responsibly is essential. Here’s what you should do:
Separate the animals safely
If it’s safe, separate the dogs to prevent further injury. Ensure your dog is leashed, secured, or properly contained to avoid any additional incidents or escalation of the situation. Take care to remain calm and composed, as panicking can sometimes make the situation worse. Use a leash or harness to restrain your dog effectively, and if necessary, seek assistance from bystanders or authorities to ensure safety.
Exchange information with the other owner
Provide your contact details and request theirs. It’s also helpful to document the other dog’s injuries, including photographs, and gather witness information, if possible. If there are bystanders, ask them to share their contact information in case they’re needed to provide statements later.
Seek veterinary care
Ensure the injured dog receives immediate medical attention. If your dog was also injured, take them to a veterinarian promptly. Addressing injuries quickly helps prevent complications and provides clear documentation if legal or insurance issues arise later.
Notify local animal control
In many cases, you’re required by law to report the incident to animal control authorities. Be cooperative but cautious when providing information, as this may influence any investigation or legal decisions related to your case. Clearly explain the situation while avoiding unnecessary details.
Consult an attorney
Protecting your rights and your dog’s future is crucial. A lawyer experienced in dog bite cases can guide you through legal proceedings and help mitigate potential consequences.
What if my dog is declared dangerous?
If your dog is declared dangerous, it may face restrictions or other penalties. Under New Jersey law, a “dangerous dog” designation can occur if your pet has caused significant harm to another domestic animal. Once a dog is labeled dangerous, you may be required to:
- Muzzle your dog in public.
- Display warning signs on your property.
- Obtain special liability insurance.
These restrictions can be burdensome, but they are not automatic. You have the right to challenge this designation in court. Evidence such as your dog’s history, obedience training, or mitigating circumstances can help your case. Legal representation is often critical in these situations, as the process can be complex and emotionally charged.
Need legal help for your dog bite case?
At Varcadipane & Pinnisi, P.C., we understand the emotional and legal challenges that come with incidents involving your beloved pet. If you’re concerned about your rights or your dog’s future, contact our experienced attorneys at (201) 588-1500. Let us help you protect what matters most.
Sophia Soraya
Sophia Soraya is a seasoned attorney specializing in complex civil matters, with a focus on personal injury, professional malpractice, and product liability cases across New York and New Jersey. Sophia is a Partner with the Firm and has been selected as a Super Lawyers, Rising Star for consecutive years and has been recognized by the National Trial Lawyers.
University: J.D. New England Law (Boston)
Bar Number: 000402013
Locations: New Jersey and New York.
Let Us Fight For You
Need Help? Contact us 24/7
Free Consultation
(800) 616-2916
New York & New Jersey Personal Injury & Litigation Lawyers

